Demystifying Discrimination Pricing Strategy for Small Business Owners 🧛🏻♂️
Suppose you run a small café in Sydney. Two customers walk in, both eyeing your popular flat white. One is a student; the other is a corporate professional. You’ve often wondered—could you charge them differently based on what they’re willing to pay? This idea, known as the discrimination pricing strategy, might seem unfair at first glance, but when done ethically and strategically, it can boost your profits while keeping customers happy.
>Download Now: Free PDF How To Drive Pricing Strategy To Accelerate Sales & EBIT Growth
However, price discrimination is often misunderstood, especially in the context of Australian small businesses. Let’s unpack how this strategy works, how regulations shape it, and how you can combine it with value-based pricing to build loyalty.
Understanding Discrimination Pricing Strategy
At its core, price discrimination means charging different prices to different customers for the same product or service. It’s not about trickery—it’s about aligning prices with the value customers perceive. Airlines, for example, do this every day, offering cheaper tickets to early bookers and premium prices closer to the departure date.
For small businesses, price discrimination can take many forms. A hair salon might offer discounts to pensioners on weekdays, while a bakery may charge slightly more for custom cakes than for ready-made ones. These strategies make sense, but they can also raise eyebrows. Are you being fair to all your customers?
3 Degrees of Price Discrimination
Discrimination pricing isn’t a one-size-fits-all strategy. It comes in three distinct degrees, each with its own application and ethical considerations.
First-Degree Price Discrimination
This involves charging each customer the maximum price they are willing to pay. It’s the most personalised form of price discrimination but is often impractical for small businesses. For example, a freelance graphic designer might quote different rates for projects based on what a client can afford or the perceived value of the work. While this approach can maximise profits, it requires detailed knowledge of each customer’s willingness to pay, which isn’t always feasible.
Second-Degree Price Discrimination
This form offers price variations based on the quantity purchased or the customer’s choice of product. Bulk discounts are a common example, such as a small grocer offering lower prices for a dozen eggs than for a single carton. Another example is tiered pricing, where customers pay less per unit as they consume more. This degree is more widely used in small businesses as it’s easier to implement and explain to customers.
Third-Degree Price Discrimination
This involves segmenting customers into groups based on specific characteristics, such as age, location, or profession, and charging different prices to each group. A hair salon offering discounts for students or seniors during off-peak hours is a classic example. It’s one of the most accessible forms of price discrimination for small businesses, provided it is implemented transparently and aligns with customer expectations.
The Legality of Price Discrimination in Australia
In Australia, the discrimination pricing strategy is not outright illegal, but it must comply with competition laws. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) ensures that businesses don’t misuse this strategy to harm competitors or exploit customers. For instance, if you’re a florist offering different rates for bulk orders, you can’t inflate prices for smaller businesses to stifle competition.
Moreover, transparency is key. Australian consumers value honesty, and hidden price variations can backfire. Small businesses need to strike a balance—tailoring prices to customer segments without breaching trust or laws.
The Ethics and Benefits of Discrimination Pricing Strategy
This is where many small business owners feel conflicted. Is it fair to charge a single mum less for her groceries while her neighbour pays full price? The answer often lies in the intention. Price discrimination can be a tool for inclusivity when applied thoughtfully.
For example, consider a gym that offers discounted memberships for students and low-income earners. This doesn’t just boost access to fitness—it builds goodwill and fosters loyalty. On the flip side, ethical concerns arise when businesses exploit customers who lack options. Charging higher prices in remote areas, where competition is limited, can damage reputations and alienate customers.
The key is balancing profit with fairness. Customers are more likely to accept price differences if they see the value behind them.
Common Missteps in Price Discrimination
One common mistake is assuming all customers will respond positively to price variations. A small retailer might offer discounts to seniors but forget that younger shoppers also value savings. Or a restaurant might implement peak-time pricing without explaining the rationale, leaving diners feeling cheated.
Another pitfall is relying solely on discounts. While lower prices can attract new customers, they don’t always build loyalty. Customers drawn by discounts often switch to competitors once the deals disappear.
Is a Discrimination Pricing Strategy Right for Your Business?
A discrimination pricing strategy can work well for small businesses—but only in the right situations. It means charging different prices to different customer groups for the same product or service. Sometimes that’s smart. Other times, it can backfire.
Let’s say you run a tutoring service. Offering student discounts makes sense. Students want help but can’t always pay full price. You still fill your schedule and build loyalty. That’s when a discrimination pricing strategy is beneficial—it helps attract more customers without cutting prices across the board.
Now imagine you run a bakery and start charging higher prices on weekends. If customers feel it’s unfair or random, they may stop coming altogether. That’s when the strategy isn’t helpful—it confuses people or damages trust.
So, how do you know if it suits your business? Start by asking:
- Do I serve different customer groups with different needs or budgets?
- Can I explain the pricing clearly and fairly?
- Will the benefit outweigh the risk of upsetting loyal customers?
Also, test on a small scale. For example, try offering targeted discounts for students or seniors and see how they respond. Use feedback, not guesswork.
A discrimination pricing strategy works best when it feels helpful, not sneaky. It suits service-based businesses, membership models, or any place where value means different things to different people. But if your customers expect one clear price, it might do more harm than good.
In short, know your audience. Be transparent. And always ask—does this pricing build trust, or break it? That’s your answer.
How to Price Products in a Small Business by Balancing Price Discrimination with Customer Value
Here’s where the magic happens: blending discrimination pricing strategy with value-based pricing. Instead of focusing only on what customers will pay, consider what they value most.
Understand Your Market: Know who your customers are and what they value. Use surveys or casual conversations to gather insights.
Stay Transparent: Clearly explain price variations. Customers are more likely to accept them if they understand the rationale.
Comply with Regulations: Familiarise yourself with ACCC guidelines to ensure your pricing strategies align with Australian laws.
Focus on Value: Combine price discrimination with value-based pricing. Offer services or products that justify the price differences.
Test and Refine: Experiment with small changes before rolling out a broader strategy. Monitor customer feedback and adjust as needed.
Simple Examples of a Discrimination Pricing Strategy in Small Businesses
A discrimination pricing strategy isn’t just for big brands. Small businesses use it too—often without realising. It’s about charging different prices to different customer groups, based on what they value and can afford. When used well, it helps both the business and the customer.
Take a local gym, for example. It offers cheaper memberships for students and seniors. That’s a classic discrimination pricing strategy. These groups still get full access, but pay less. Why? They value the service, but their budget is tight. The gym fills more slots and builds long-term loyalty.
Or think about a florist who charges extra for same-day delivery. The flowers are the same, but the urgency adds value. Customers with last-minute needs are happy to pay more. That’s another form of price discrimination—based on timing.
Now picture a weekend market stall selling handmade candles. The seller offers bundle discounts—buy two, get one half price. This encourages bigger purchases without cutting the price for everyone. It rewards bulk buyers, not casual ones. Again, it’s a smart discrimination pricing strategy.
Even a tradie might use it. They could offer lower rates for weekday work but charge more for weekends. This matches price to demand, without punishing anyone.
The key is balance. Each example offers real value to the customer, not just higher prices. As a business consultant, I always say: the goal isn’t to squeeze more from one group, but to match prices with value.
Done right, a discrimination pricing strategy builds trust, attracts varied customers, and boosts revenue—all without losing fairness.
>>> Setup A Meeting With An Expert <<<
A New Perspective on Discrimination Pricing Strategy
Price discrimination doesn’t have to be a dirty phrase. For Australian small businesses, it can be a powerful tool to balance fairness, loyalty, and profit. By understanding your customers, respecting their needs, and staying true to your values, you can turn pricing challenges into opportunities.
So, the next time you wonder whether to offer a student discount or premium pricing for exclusive services, remember—it’s not just about the price. It’s about the value you create and the trust you build.
If you’re ready to rethink your pricing or need guidance on what’s right for your business, let’s start the conversation. Your customers—and your bottom line—will thank you. Reach out today, and let’s make your pricing strategy stronger together.
For a comprehensive view of ensuring the continuous growth of your business, Download a complimentary brochure on How To Drive Pricing Strategy To Accelerate Sales & EBIT Growth.
Are you a small or medium-sized business in need of help aligning your pricing strategy, people and operations to deliver an immediate impact on profit?
If so, please call (+61) 2 8607 7001.
You can also email us at team@valueculture.com if you have any further questions.
